Reserved List Magic Cards: What They Are and Why They Hold Value
The Reserved List is a promise from Wizards of the Coast never to reprint certain early Magic cards, and that promise is one of the main reasons those cards keep their value.
Published
What the Reserved List actually is
The Reserved List is a published list of Magic: The Gathering cards that Wizards of the Coast has promised never to reprint in a form that can be played in tournaments. It was created in the game's early years, after collectors worried that heavy reprinting of old cards would wipe out the value of what they already owned.
The list is made up of cards from Magic's earliest sets, running from Alpha and Beta through to the Urza's block era. Not every old card is on it. Wizards chose specific cards, mostly rares and a handful of uncommons, and the list has been closed for many years, so nothing new gets added.
The important thing to understand is that the promise applies to the card name, not to one particular printing. If a card is on the Reserved List, every legal printing of it is affected, whether that is a Beta copy or a later core set copy.
Why a promise not to reprint matters so much
Most Magic cards can be reprinted whenever Wizards decides players need more copies. When a popular card gets a new printing, more copies enter the market and the price of older copies often softens. Reserved List cards are protected from that.
Because the supply of tournament-legal copies can only ever shrink, as cards get damaged, lost or locked away in collections, the number available to players and collectors does not grow. At the same time, formats such as Vintage and Legacy still allow these cards, so there is ongoing demand from people who want to play with them, not just own them.
That combination of fixed supply and steady demand is why Reserved List cards have tended to hold their value better than most cards from the same era. It is not a guarantee, and prices still move with the wider market, but the risk of a sudden reprint pulling the floor out is removed.
Which cards are on the list
The best-known names are the Power Nine, including Black Lotus and the Moxen, along with the original dual lands such as Underground Sea, Volcanic Island and Tropical Island. These are the cards most people picture when they hear the phrase Reserved List.
Beyond those headline cards, the list includes plenty of rares that are less famous but still sought after, such as Gaea's Cradle, Lion's Eye Diamond and The Tabernacle at Pendrell Vale. It also includes a large number of cards that were never strong in play and see little demand today.
That last point matters. Being on the Reserved List does not make a card valuable by itself. A weak card that nobody wants to play or collect stays cheap whether it can be reprinted or not. The list protects value where demand already exists; it does not create demand out of nothing.
How to check whether your card is on the Reserved List
Start by reading the card name carefully and noting the set symbol, or the lack of one, since Alpha, Beta, Unlimited and Revised cards have no set symbol at all. Then search the name on a card database. Scryfall lets you search with the term is:reserved to show only Reserved List cards, and individual card pages there also mark when a card is on the list.
If the name is on the list, the next job is working out which printing you have. Alpha cards have noticeably rounded corners, Beta and Unlimited have sharper corners, and Unlimited and Revised cards have white borders rather than black. Each of these differences can change the value of the same card name considerably.
Finally, look at condition. Reserved List cards are old, and many have been played hard over the decades. Whitening on the edges, creases, scuffs and fading all count, and on older cards the gap between a clean copy and a played one can be large. A quick photo scan with SnapCardValue can identify the card and show what similar copies have actually sold for, which is a sensible first step before you look into grading or selling.
Copies that look the same but are not tournament legal
Wizards has found ways to print Reserved List cards without breaking the promise, by making the copies not legal for tournament play. Collectors' Edition and International Edition sets from the early years have square corners and different backs. World Championship decks have gold borders and different backs. Later premium anniversary products also reprinted these cards with non-standard backs.
These copies are real, official products, but they sit in a different part of the market from the original printings. If you have a card with a gold border, square corners or a back that does not match a normal Magic card, check exactly what it is before assuming it carries the value of the tournament-legal version.
Reserved List cards are also among the most counterfeited cards in Magic, because their value makes faking them worthwhile. If a high-value Reserved List card comes your way, check the printing, the back, the font and the light test, or have it looked at by a grading company before relying on it.
Should you buy or hold Reserved List cards
Many collectors see Reserved List cards as the most dependable part of the Magic market, and over the long run they have often behaved that way. Even so, they are collectibles rather than savings accounts. Prices rise and fall with interest in the game, the health of the wider collectibles market and the popularity of formats like Vintage, Legacy and Commander.
If you have inherited or found old cards, it is worth checking each rare against the list before selling anything as a bundle. A single Reserved List card in a box of old commons can be worth more than everything else combined. Take your time, identify each card properly and compare against recent realised sales rather than asking prices.
Your questions, answered.
What is the Magic: The Gathering Reserved List?
It is a list of early Magic cards that Wizards of the Coast has promised never to reprint in a tournament-legal form. The list is closed, so no new cards are added to it.
Is Black Lotus on the Reserved List?
Yes. Black Lotus and the rest of the Power Nine are on the Reserved List, along with the original dual lands such as Underground Sea and Volcanic Island.
Does being on the Reserved List make a card valuable?
Not on its own. The list stops new tournament-legal copies being made, which protects value where people already want the card, but many Reserved List cards see little demand and remain cheap.
How can I check if my Magic card is on the Reserved List?
Search the card name on Scryfall, which marks Reserved List cards on their pages and lets you filter with is:reserved. Then check which printing you have and its condition, since both affect value.
Are Collectors' Edition cards Reserved List reprints?
They are official printings of many Reserved List cards, but they have square corners and different backs and are not legal in tournaments, so they are valued differently from the original printings.
Will Wizards of the Coast ever reprint Reserved List cards?
Wizards has repeatedly said it intends to keep the Reserved List promise for tournament-legal printings. It has issued non-tournament-legal versions with different backs or borders, which do not break the promise.